In a plot twist nobody saw coming, JK Rowling is facing a severe backlash over her new ‘cross-dressing serial killer’ book
JK Rowling found herself on the receiving end of a severe backlash – again – after an early review revealed that her new book features a cis male serial killer who likes to dress as a woman.
Troubled Blood, released under Rowling’s Robert Galbraith pseudonym, was described by a Telegraph review as a “book whose moral seems to be: never trust a man in a dress”.
Reviewer Jake Kerridge revealed that the “meat” of the 900-page novel is an investigation into a cold case: the disappearance of a woman believed the be the victim of a cross-dressing serial killer.
As news of the plot spread on Twitter, users expressed their profound disappointment in Rowling’s new literary direction.
Writer Paris Lees noted that while Rowling writes about a cross-dressing serial killer, ‘the number of trans people killed in Brazil has risen by 70 per cent this past year, young trans women are left to burn in cars and men who kill us (for being trans) are pardoned and sent home’.
I know a lot of you who follow me probably share some of the fears around the myth about "men who dress up as women to hurt women". If I wasn't trans I suspect I would too.
But I ask you to look inside your heart and question what is really happening here https://t.co/cdYE2TKmkt
— Paris Lees (@parislees) September 14, 2020
Academic and writer Priyamvada Gopal wondered why the author had chosen a man dressed as a woman, when ‘the world is so full of evil beings and villainous forces’.
The amazing thing is that the world is so full of evil beings & villainous forces–pogromists, lynchers, mass rapists, starvers, militias, bomb-makers, weapons manufacturers, sweatshop owners, ecocidal profiteers– but writer could only settle on 'man dressed as woman'.
— Priyamvada Gopal (@PriyamvadaGopal) September 15, 2020
Writer Nick Cohen defended Troubled Blood, arguing that its ending negates ‘the claim it’s anti-trans’, but conceding that the author’s ‘enemies’ will ‘hate’ the book because ‘it is however very feminist’.
It is however very feminist, so some of JK's enemies will hate it for that
— Nick Cohen (@NickCohen4) September 14, 2020
However YouTuber Kat Blaque took a different view. Simply that ‘JK Rowling could have just… not done all of this’.
JK Rowling could have just…not done all of this and her trans fans (there are lots) would have continued to support her. I'm glad she's being honest about it. You really can't write a 900 page transphobic fantasy and then say "I'm not transphobic"
— Mona Lisa Needsa Treatsa (@kat_blaque) September 14, 2020
GLAAD condemn ‘lazy’ cross-dresser trope.
GLAAD director of transgender representation Nick Adams noted that the book follows in a long tradition of “films, TV shows, and books using the ‘cross-dressing psychopathic killer’ trope”, which “have been created over and over by cisgender people”.
“This false and lazy storytelling device is based not in reality but in thinly-disguised homophobia and transphobia, and conflates gender non-conformity with evil,” Adams told PinkNews.
“Gender expression isn’t a danger to others. These false narratives put real transgender and gender non-conforming people in harm’s way.”
JK Rowling finished new book in December.
According to the Independent, Troubled Blood centres around a cis male serial killer who “fetishises women’s clothing, and in one instance in the book, disguises himself as a woman to trick the person he is abducting”.
It’s Rowling’s first adult novel to be released since she dove head-first into the conversation on trans lives with a heavily-criticised essay.
Titled “TERF Wars”, the essay saw the author explain that her new-found interest in trans lives was, in part, related to her Cormoran Strike series, of which Troubled Blood is the fifth entry.
“On one level, my interest in this issue has been professional, because I’m writing a crime series, set in the present day, and my fictional female detective is of an age to be interested in, and affected by, these issues herself,” she wrote.
More from PinkNews
“On another, it’s intensely personal,” she added, noting among other things her personal experience with domestic and sexual assault, and wrongly conflated gender identity with mental health.
The essay was published 10 June, five months after Rowling announced on Twitter she had finished the manuscript for what would become Troubled Blood, and six months after she spoke out on behalf of Maya Forstater – a woman who sought to have her “gender-critical” views protected under the UK Equalities Act.
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) January 25, 2020