Menu

InstagramTwitterYouTubeFacebookSnapchat
Globe Icon
Current Affairs

Gay couples must be allowed to adopt, rules federal judge

Josh Jackman July 16, 2018
A gay male couple representing same-sex couples who have a child through an adoption agency

The ruling came as Republicans in Congress attempt to push for legal discrimination (AdobeStock)

A federal judge has slapped down a lawsuit from a Christian adoption and fostering group which was censured for discriminating against same-sex couples.

Bethany Christian Services and Catholic Social Services (CSS) – which have received around 3 million in funding from Philadelphia City Council – were had their contracts suspended in March after an investigation revealed they were refusing to place kids with gay people.

Bethany agreed to comply but CSS challenged the decision with a lawsuit, stating that it should receive a religious exemption to the city’s anti-discrimination rules.

Corine (L) and Audrey Schep sign, along with their child Dieuwke, the first certificate of approvalthe first certificate of approval for a co-mother at the Zwolle city hall, The Netherlands, on April 1, 2014. Lesbian couples are now able to be both legal parents of a child of one of them, without going through complicated and costly procedures. AFP PHOTO / ANP - JERRY LAMPEN = netherlands out        (Photo credit should read JERRY LAMPEN/AFP/Getty Images)
CSS has filed a notice of appeal against the ruling (JERRY LAMPEN/AFP/Getty)

US District Judge Petrese Tucker has rejected the agency’s suit, handing down her decision as Republicans in Congress continue to push for an amendment which would allow discrimination against prospective gay parents.

The judge found that CSS had broken both city law and its own contract in refusing to place children with same-sex couples.

She also dismissed the idea that CSS was being made to violate its religious principles by enabling gay people to foster or adopt children.

SALT LAKE CITY, UT - NOVEMBER 9: Candice Green Barret (R) and her wife Megan Barrett (L) with their children Quinn and Tucker Pose for a picture at a rally and party in support of gay and lesbian families sponsored by the Utah Pride Center on November 9, 2015 in Salt Lake City, Utah. Last week the Mormon Church announced changes to their policies to  classify people who enter into gay and lesbian marriages as apostates and ban their children from being blessed and baptized into the Mormon Church. Neither on of the Barret's children will be able to be baptized into the Mormon Church because their lesbian parents were married. (Photo by George Frey/Getty Images
The judge dismissed the idea that CSS was being made to violate its religious principles (George Frey/Getty)

“The Services Contract does not require CSS to express its religious approval or disapproval of persons seeking out its services,” Tucker wrote in her decision.

“In essence, if CSS provides its services consistent with the minimal requirements of the all-comers provisions of the Fair Practices Ordinance, then CSS may continue to provide foster care to children.

“This does not constitute a substantial burden on CSS’s religious exercise of providing foster care to children,” she added.

The judge also made it clear that CSS’s argument about foster children losing out as a result of the city potentially cancelling its contract with CSS did not hold up.

WASHINGTON - APRIL 17:  Doug Metcalfe (L) and his partner Brian Lahmann show their White House Easter Egg Roll event tickets to their daughter, Helen Lahmann-Metcalfe, 4, after picking up the tickets April 17, 2006 in Washington, DC. Members and supporters of Family Pride, a gay and lesbian parents' organization, wore rainbow-colored leis while attending to the 128-year-old event.  (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
Oklahoma and Kansas have both passed laws this year enabling agencies to discriminate against same-sex couples (Chip Somodevilla/Getty)

The city, she wrote, had “offered evidence showing that the closure of CSS’s intake of new referrals has had little or no effect on the operation of Philadelphia’s foster care system.”

CSS has filed a notice of appeal.

This year, Oklahoma and Kansas have both passed laws enabling agencies to discriminate against same-sex couples wanting to adopt or foster children.

In May, Oklahoma’s Republican Governor Mary Fallin signed Senate Bill 1140 after it was passed by the state’s House and Senate, meaning that it will come into effect on November 1.

Oklahoma Governor Mary Fallin speaks on the last day of the Republican National Convention on July 21, 2016, in Cleveland, Ohio. / AFP / JIM WATSON        (Photo credit should read JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty Images)
Oklahoma Governor Mary Fallin signed the bill into law in May (JIM WATSON/AFP/Getty)

And in the same month, Republican Governor Jeff Colyer did the same for his state of Kansas.

In 2016, a federal judge ruled that Mississippi’s ban on same-sex couples adopting children was unconstitutional – making same-sex adoption legal in all 50 states.

But many states have tried to find ways around this ruling, mostly through the idea that there should be a religious exception for people and agencies who believe LGB people should not be parents because of their faith.

Nine states – including Alabama, Michigan, Mississippi, North Dakota, South Dakota, Texas and Virginia – have managed to pass a law of this kind, which enables agencies to discriminate against same-sex couples.

More: adoption, Children, court, fostering, Gay, Law, Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, same sex couples, US, US

Read comments (0)

Close icon