BBC called out for inviting ‘jail the gays’ leader to debate LGBT rights
The BBC staged a ‘balanced debate’ on gay police officers today between an LGBT rights campaigner and a hardline fringe politician who opposed the decriminalisation of homosexuality.
BBC Radio Ulster today aired a segment on current affairs show Good Morning Ulster about the Police Service of Northern Ireland’s engagement with the LGBT community.
Northern Ireland was the last part of the UK to decriminalise gay sex in 1982, after a European court ruling struck down the region’s anti-gay buggery and gross indecency laws.
Prior to partial decriminalisation, the LGBT community was extensively targeted by police – and PSNI’s events are aimed at rebuilding relations and bolstering LGBT representation on the force.
But in its coverage, the BBC decided to hold a debate between Gavin Boyd of the Rainbow Project and fringe politician Jim Allister.
A hardline opponent of LGBT rights, Allister – whose Traditional Union Voice party holds just one seat in the NI Assembly – strongly opposed the decriminalisaton of gay sex in Northern Ireland.
He confirmed his views had not changed has in 2015, saying: “In the 1980s I opposed the legislative change that was made [to legalise gay sex]… gay sex to me is an obnoxious thing.”
When the BBC presented the discussion about gay police officers as a balanced debate between two sides, Mr Boyd raised his opponent’s history.
He said: “I think it’s really important to remember that when people like Jim Allister are opposed to this, it’s not in isolation.
“Jim Allister supported the criminalisation of gay and bisexual men in Northern Ireland, and perhaps he would rather that instead of the police recruiting LGBT people, they were still locking us up.”
The BBC host cut in: “OK, well I think we’re moving away from what we’re trying to concentrate on today. Jim, would you like to respond to those comments?”
In his response Mr Allister did not clarify whether he still supports the criminalisation pf homosexuality.
When the host attempted to ask a question, Mr Allister cut in: “Could you just for one moment restrain your BBC bias on this subject?”
It’s not the first time the BBC has invited anti-LGBT activists to ‘debate’ with gay people.
Representatives of anti-LGBT lobbying group Christian Concern have made no fewer than 30 appearances across BBC platforms in the last year, including on the BBC’s flagship news and current affairs programmes.
The group has ties to gay ‘cure’ practitioners and has lobbied against basic protections for LGBT people in the UK.
Radio 4’s Today programme recently faced complaints after failing to disclose that ‘parents’ invited to speak about transgender rights were actually managed by Christian Concern.
Meanwhile, Mr Allister faced a conduct complaint earlier this year after attempting to smear PinkNews.
The smear was an apparent retaliation to a report that he had allegedly offered an informal pact with the Democratic Unionist Party to help block equal marriage in Northern Ireland – overriding a democratic majority of support for the measure in the Northern Ireland Assembly.
The politician had signalled that he would help the DUP employ a ‘petition of concern’ to hinder LGBT rights, explaining: “TUV is a party committed to traditional family values and will continue to resist attempts by the homosexual lobby to introduce the oxymoron which is same sex marriage to Northern Ireland.”
Last year, Mr Allister was the only MLA in Northern Ireland to vote against the extension of pardons to men with historical gay sex convictions.
He said: “The House in 2016, in its arrogance, thinks that it can take it upon itself to rewrite the law of 40 years ago.
“It cannot, and it should not. The law was the law. If those who chose to break the law, knowing what the law was, paid a penalty, that was the law taking its course, whether they were homosexual or heterosexual.
“It is now so fashionable to jump on board the LGBT bandwagon that you simply abandon all principles and leave your beliefs outside the door.”
The police force announced this week that it is holding a recruitment event to find officers from the LGBT community.
The two events, which will be held in Belfast next month, are billed as “information evenings for the LGBTQ+ community”.
Officials explained: “At these events you’ll be able to find out more information on the recruitment process and hear about the experiences of serving LGBT+ Police officers in the Police Service.
“Both events will feature a panel of serving officers and Human resources staff there to answer your questions relating to the recruitment process and about the exciting career possibilities in the Police Service.”
LGBT campaigners have welcomed the outreach, which is the first of its kind in Northern Ireland – and comes after historically poor relations between police and LGBT people.
The PSNI hopes the events will help mend bridges – and bolster LGBT representation inside the force.
PSNI Deputy Chief Constable Drew Harris said: “As part of our ongoing engagement towards under-represented groups within our organisation we have been working closely with a number of external agencies and we will be holding a number of information sessions regarding our current recruitment campaign.
“The Police Service of Northern Ireland is committed to ensuring our workforce is totally representative of the community we serve and that we are seen as an employer of choice.”
One of the events will be held at the Belfast Trans Resource Centre on November 6, while a second event will he held at The Rainbow Project’s HQ on November 8.
PSNI officers at Belfast Pride and Irish leader Leo Varadkar (Photo by Charles McQuillan/Getty Images)
However, the move came under fire from Mr Allister,
He said: “I think it’s totally unwarranted pandering to a group already protected with full equality laws in the law.
“It’s already unlawful to discriminate in employment on grounds of sexual orientation, so why does the PSNI think it necessary to go beyond that for this section of society?
“It should be the merit principle that governs recruitment and that alone and now we are going to bend the merit principle… is that what we’re talking about? It seems to be a politically correct thing to do.”
Gavin Boyd of the Rainbow Project promptly rebutted his comments on air.
He saod: “No-one has suggested that merit won’t dictate who’s employed by the PSNI, and that’s a ridiculous comment for Jim Allister to make, to say that merit is going to be suspended.
“What the PSNI are doing is recognising that due to the troubled legacy of criminalisation of our community, which Jim Allister supported at the time, there’s a tension between our community and the police service in Northern Ireland, and that has impacted on the police’s ability to recruit from this community.
“I think it’s a really welcome step that’s part of their wider programme of engagement that police are actually going to those places where LGBT people are, to make it really plain that they support the ability for LGBT people to be recruited into the police, be promoted throught the police and protect people across Northern Ireland.
“I’m glad we’ve been able to support it by allowing our centers to be opened up as a recruitment site.”
Mr Boyd added: “Jim Allister is obviously a bit hysterical and emotional this morning, but over the past 20 years there have been substantial reforms to policing in Northern Ireland to make it more accountable and human rights compliant.
“A part of that is making sure the police service reflects the community it seeks to serve. There have been many campaigns to recruit from under-represented communities.
“A service that reflects the community can provide a better service to the community. I think this is a really important step to make sure it reflects the LGBT community as well.”