Assault on trans woman not a hate crime

By Lydia Malmedie • July 4, 2007 - 10:11

In June 2006, the then 17-year old had beaten a 39-year old trans-woman, according to his attorney out of self-defence.

3 Comments on Assault on trans woman not a hate crime

A teenager has been found guilty of aggravated battery, but not of hate crime by a juvenile judge in Palm Beach Country, Florida, today.

In June 2006, the then 17-year old beat a 39-year old trans-woman, according to his attorney out of self-defence.

The woman claims that the teen was sexually aggressive towards her, although she had told him that she was not a biological woman.

The victim claims that the violence, whereby the teenager smashed her head against a lifeguard stand, resulted from her rejecting the youngster's sexual advances and not because she was a trans-woman.

She denies that they were involved in any sexual activity.

The main witness, a friend of the teenager's who was at the scene, is not talking, the attorney says.

According to the law in Florida a crime is classified as a hate-crime only when perpetrator intentionally selects a victim on the basis of characteristics like race, religion or ethnicity or sexual orientation.

Gender identity currently does not fall under federal or Florida law as a motive for hate-crime.

The culprit's attorney told the Miami Herald.com that the incident does not meet the definition of a hate-crime because his client did not "intentionally select" the victim.

The victim, who has lived for over a decade as a woman, says she wants the teen to face consequences for the beating but does not want to see him charged as an adult.

"I guess I'm a little more compassionate. … I didn't want to destroy his life," with a felony charge in adult court, she told the Miami Herald.com .

The teenager, who had been under house arrest since the incident last year, will return to court next month for his sentence hearing.

Share this story with the world These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.