A California appellate court’s June 9 ruling was the latest in a series of recent developments that return disputed church properties to three California Episcopal dioceses.
On June 9, the San Diego-based Fourth District Court of Appeal ruled unanimously that the Diocese of Los Angeles is legal owner of property currently occupied by St. Luke’s Anglican Church. The congregation had cited theological differences when severing ties to the Episcopal Church (TEC) in 2006 and realigning with an Anglican diocese in Uganda.
In unrelated agreements, displaced Episcopalians will return July 1 to two other disputed properties, St. John’s Church in Petaluma, in the Diocese of Northern California and St. Paul’s Church in Modesto in the Diocese of San Joaquin.
“The long history of the Episcopal Church in La Crescenta will continue with new leadership and the potential for sustained growth, and as an open source of full inclusion for all humanity,” Bishop Jon Bruno of Los Angeles said June 9 after learning of the court’s decision.
“It is important that we preserve the essence of St. Luke the healer and the ongoing maintenance of the historic church building. It is a jewel in the crown of La Crescenta, and a blessing to the people of the Diocese of Los Angeles.”
Los Angeles: ‘property held in trust’ for wider church
The appellate court ruling affirmed a 2007 trial court decision that the church, located about 15 miles north of Los Angeles, was held in trust for the mission of both the local diocese and the wider church. In issuing the ruling, the ten-member panel cited a January 5, 2009 California Supreme Court decision, which returned St. James Anglican Church in Newport Beach to the diocese. Attorneys in that case, New v. Kroeger, have appealed the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court.
John Shiner, chancellor for the Diocese of Los Angeles, said a timeline for transition will advance in accordance with court procedures.
The Rev. Rob Holmann, rector of St. Luke’s Anglican Church, declined to comment June 10. “I know the general direction of the ruling, but I am withholding all comment until I see it” and until he could speak with attorneys, he told the Episcopal News Service.
A few days earlier, Holmann had told the Glendale News Press that he and the 200-member congregation “would very much like to stay” in the 83-year-old river-rock building, considered a cultural, architectural and historic local landmark.
Bruno said the future mission of St. Luke’s, now under his direct pastoral control, will be to focus on “deepening our understanding of what it means to be reconciled, welcoming and healthy people of God.”
Petaluma and Modesto: Episcopal congregations set to return July 1
After a bitter split and three years of “homelessness,” members of St. John’s Episcopal Church in Petaluma are returning July 1 to the 118-year-old church, the Rev. Norman Cram said in a telephone interview June 10.
“We are jubilant, overwhelmingly jubilant,” said Cram, priest-in-charge. “We celebrated our homelessness and we overlooked the inconveniences of living and worshipping out of a laundry basket but now that these things are almost behind us, it’s almost overwhelming.”
Citing disagreement over the ordination of a gay bishop, a majority of the 250-member congregation in December 2006 had voted to sever ties with the Episcopal Church and the Diocese of Northern California but declined to vacate church property. They formed St. John’s Anglican Church, displacing about 55 continuing Episcopalians who initially met in homes.
The Rev. David Miller, rector of the Anglican congregation, had sought a transfer of his canonical residence to the Argentina-based Anglican Province of the Southern Cone and was eventually deposed by the Rt. Rev. Jerry Lamb, then bishop of the Diocese of Northern California.
Miller did not return ENS telephone calls June 10. Mike McIntosh, parish administrator for the disaffiliated group, said a news release would be issued eventually, but declined further comment. The congregation’s last service in the church will be Sunday, June 28.
The continuing Episcopal congregation eventually began meeting on Sunday evenings at the Elim Lutheran Church in Petaluma who “magnificently sheltered us,” said Cram. He added that he hopes: “to present a healthy Christian perspective of love, compassion and kindness to our community, to be the yeast for the values of unity and inclusiveness in Petaluma.”
Meanwhile, Bishop Jerry Lamb of San Joaquin told ENS that discussions are underway with St. Paul’s Church in Modesto for return of that property by July 1, which several years ago affiliated with the Anglican Mission in America.
The Rev. Michael McClenaghan, rector, did not return ENS calls.
Lamb was already planning an organizational meeting, seeking lay leaders to begin the work of transition. “I have been making calls this week to laity who are or have been members of St. Paul’s and have signaled their desire to remain in the Episcopal Church,” he said in a statement posted on the diocesan website.
– The Rev. Pat McCaughan is Episcopal Life Media correspondent for Provinces VII and VIII and the House of Bishops. She is based in Los Angeles.
Tags:
Ace,
Adm,
Ads,
Ali,
Ally,
Amp,
Anc,
Anglican,
Anglican Church,
Anglican Diocese,
Appellate Court,
Appellate Court Rules,
Ased,
Attorneys,
Ba,
Bea,
Bil,
Bishops,
Blogger,
Border,
Bruno,
Cal,
Cali,
Californ,
California Appellate Court,
California Supreme Court,
Celeb,
Congregations,
Consi,
Control,
Coord,
Cop,
Cou,
Court Decision,
Court Of Appeal,
Court Ruling,
Current,
Decline,
Diocese Of San Joaquin,
Dioceses,
Direc,
Direction,
Disagreement,
District Court Of Appeal,
Dn,
Eger,
Ego,
Elon,
Episcopal,
Episcopal Church,
Episcopal Diocese,
Episcopal Dioceses,
Era,
Eric,
Erica,
Eve,
Few Days,
Fir,
Fo,
Focus,
Fourth District Court Of Appeal,
Fr,
Ganda,
gay,
Gay Bi,
Gay Bishop,
Gin,
God,
google,
Grou,
Healer,
health,
Helm,
Hes,
Hine,
Homelessness,
Images,
Inclusion,
Inclusiveness,
Jew,
Jewel In The Crown,
July 1,
Kroeger,
Landmark,
Ld,
Lea,
Lead,
Leadership,
Leads,
Lear,
Led,
Loc,
Loo,
love,
Lt,
Lutheran Church,
Map,
Member Panel,
Members,
Met,
Mis,
Mp,
Mpa,
Mu,
Nan,
Nbsp,
Newport Beach,
News Release,
News Service,
Norm,
Opm,
Oral,
Ordination,
Organization,
Original Source,
Ouse,
Pac,
Paris,
Passion,
People,
Petaluma California,
Phone Interview,
Pi,
Pl,
Pos,
Property Held In Trust,
Quin,
Rea,
Rema,
Rent,
Rig,
Rov,
Rr,
San Diego,
Shap,
Shiner,
Sig,
Sin,
Sit,
Sourc,
Spe,
St James Anglican Church,
St Luke,
Sunday Evening,
Supreme Court,
Supreme Court Decision,
Target,
Ted,
Telephone Call,
Telephone Calls,
Telephone Interview,
Tent,
Theological Differences,
Tia,
Ties,
Timeline,
Transition,
Trial Court,
Uganda,
Uni,
Url,
Vet,
Vote,
Wh,
Wit,
Wor,
Wou
By mid-afternoon, authorities reportedly had someone in custody in connection with the murder of Wichita abortion doctor George Tiller at his church on Sunday morning.
So far, we know nothing about the suspect. Though the motive for the crime we can all surmise in light of the vitriolic campaign that has been waged against Tiller for more than two decades by anti-abortion groups.
And if we’re right about that, then we already know the identities of his accomplices.
They include every one who has ever called Tiller’s late term abortion clinic a murder mill.
Who ever called Tiller “Tiller the Killer.”
The groups who spent decades fomenting hate toward a man who simply believed that he was serving a purpose by being one of the few doctors in the country performing late-term abortions.
Hate. Not heated opposition. Not strong disagreement.
But blind hatred.
The kind of hate that would prompt some maniac to take a gun into a church and shoot a man to death in front of friends and family.
His accomplices know they have blood on their hands, which might explain why they were quick to issue statements today expressing disapproval of Tiller’s murder.
Among them, the anti-abortion group Operation Rescue.
“Operation Rescue denounces the killing of abortionist Tiller,” read the headline of a new release posted on that group’s website.
Those words drip with hypocrisy.
After all, it was Operation Rescue that coined the nickname “Tiller the Killer.” It was Operation Rescue that was most responsible for ratcheting up the heated rhetoric toward Tiller over the past two decades.
The group issued the following statement today:
“We are shocked at this morning’s disturbing news that Mr. Tiller was gunned down. Operation Rescue has worked for years through peaceful, legal means, and through the proper channels to see him brought to justice. We denounce vigilantism and the cowardly act that took place this morning. We pray for Mr. Tiller’s family that they will find comfort and healing that can only be found in Jesus Christ.”
Shocked? Are any of us really shocked that it would come to this after the many years of demonizing one man?
Certainly the group’s founder, Randall Terry, didn’t seem shocked when he issued a statement that, I would suggest, provides a truer sense of how the anti-abortion movement saw today’s events:
”George Tiller was a mass-murderer. We grieve for him that he did not have time to properly prepare his soul to face God. I am more concerned that the Obama Administration will use Tiller’s killing to intimidate pro-lifers into surrendering our most effective rhetoric and actions. Abortion is still murder. And we still must call abortion by its proper name; murder.
Those men and women who slaughter the unborn are murderers according to the Law of God. We must continue to expose them in our communities and peacefully protest them at their offices and homes, and yes, even their churches.”
I’d suggest that if anyone is in need of salvation right now it’s the anti-abortion movement in Kansas and across the nation.
As Terry’s statement makes clear, the same bullet that killed George Tiller also shattered the moral underpinnings of the movement that inspired its firing.
Tags:
Abortion,
Abortion Clinic,
Abortion Doctor,
Abortionist,
Abortions,
Accomplice,
Accomplices,
Ace,
Act,
Acti,
Actio,
Adm,
Ads,
Aig,
Ali,
Ally,
Amon,
Amp,
Authorities,
Ba,
Blind Hatred,
Blogger,
Blood On Their Hands,
Border,
Cal,
Churches,
Conn,
Coord,
Cou,
Cowardly Act,
Cue,
Dea,
Decade,
Decades,
Demo,
Disagreement,
Disapproval,
Disturbing News,
Dn,
Doc,
Doctor George,
Doctors,
Era,
Eve,
events,
Expos,
Express,
Face,
Fir,
Fo,
Fr,
Friends,
Friends And Family,
gay,
George Tiller,
God,
google,
Grou,
Groups,
Hatred,
Hes,
Hypocrisy,
Images,
Ins,
Jesus,
Late Term Abortion,
Late Term Abortions,
Ld,
Lea,
Lead,
Leads,
Lear,
Led,
Loo,
Lt,
Maniac,
Map,
Men And Women,
Mid Afternoon,
Mis,
Mp,
Mpa,
Mu,
Murderer,
Murderers,
Mus,
Nbsp,
Nick,
Nod,
Obama,
Offi,
Operation Rescue,
Opposition,
Oral,
Original Source,
Pac,
Pi,
Pl,
Pos,
Prom,
Proper Channels,
Protest,
Rea,
Rh,
Rhetoric,
Rig,
Rio,
Rov,
Rr,
Sens,
Shap,
Shock,
Sin,
Sit,
Span,
Spe,
Sunday Morning,
Target,
Ted,
Tent,
Ties,
Time T,
Tis,
Underpinnings,
Uni,
Ups,
Url,
Vet,
Vigil,
Vigilantism,
Wh,
Wit,
Wor,
Wou
The United Methodist Church’s highest court has ruled that clergy may not officiate at same-sex unions, even in states where such marriages are legal, and gave the final OK for the George W. Bush Library to be built at Southern Methodist University.
The church’s nine-member Judicial Council rejected separate resolutions passed by the California-Nevada and California-Pacific Conferences that voiced support for clergy who officiate at such unions.
Last year, the 8.3 million-member church upheld rules in its Book of Discipline, or constitution, that Methodist churches cannot be used to host same-sex unions and clergy are prohibited from officiating at them.
The latest court ruling rejected a California-Nevada resolution that supported retired clergy who volunteered to conduct gay weddings, and a California-Pacific resolution upholding the “pastoral need and prophetic authority” of clergy to do so.
Between May and November, 2008, California allowed same-sex couples to marry until voters banned the practiced with a constitutional amendment.
“An annual conference may not legally negate, ignore or violate provisions of the Discipline with which they disagree, even when the disagreements are based on conscientious objections to the provisions,” the court ruled, according to United Methodist News Service.
In a separate case, the court said it found no reason to halt construction of the planned George W. Bush Presidential Center at the church-owned school in Dallas.
Critics contend the library complex and affiliated policy center will promote policies that the United Methodist Church officially opposed, including the Iraq War. The former president and his wife, Laura, are both United Methodists.
Beliefnet.com
Tags:
Act,
Ali,
Ally,
Amp,
Ased,
Ba,
Belief,
Beliefnet,
Blog Blogspot,
Blogger,
Border,
Bush,
Cal,
Cali,
California Pacific,
Cho,
Churches,
Clergy,
Conscientious Objections,
Constitution,
Constitutional Amendment,
Coord,
Cou,
Coupl,
Couples,
Disagreement,
Disagreements,
Dys,
Eve,
Fo,
Former President,
Fr,
gay,
gay marriage,
Gay Wedding,
Gay Weddings,
George W Bush,
George W Bush Library,
google,
Hes,
Images,
Iraq,
Iraq War,
Judicia,
Lead,
Leads,
Led,
Lowe,
Lt,
Map,
Marr,
marriage,
Met,
Methodist Churches,
Methodist News Service,
Mp,
Nbsp,
Objections,
Oral,
Original Source,
Pac,
Pacific Conferences,
Pastoral Need,
Pl,
Pos,
president,
Prom,
Provision,
Provisions,
Rov,
Rr,
Same Sex Couples,
Same Sex Unions,
sex,
Sex Couple,
Sex Couples,
Shap,
Sig,
Sit,
Southern Methodist University,
Span,
Target,
Ted,
Tg,
Tia,
Uni,
Unions,
United Methodist Church,
United Methodist News,
United Methodist News Service,
United Methodists,
Vet,
Voiced Support,
Vote,
Weddings,
Wh
SAN DIEGO, CA - The Association of American Law Schools (AALS) 2009 Annual Meeting will feature programs devoted to the discussion of Proposition 8, as well as Same-Sex Rights. The Annual Meeting will take place on January 6-10, 2009, in San Diego.
Democracy’s Dilemma: The Case of Proposition 8, an AALS Executive Committee Roundtable program, will examine the November, 2008 vote which overturned a state Supreme Court decision that had upheld the legality of same-sex marriage. The election and its aftermath sparked deep disagreements about the rule of law and the nature of the democratic process. Supporters of same-sex marriage questioned whether a direct initiative was the appropriate way to make policy when fundamental civil rights were at stake. Defenders of the proposition argued that marriage is a cultural institution reflecting venerable traditions, making a vote of the people entirely appropriate. The role of the courts, the meaning of marriage, the scope of civil rights protections, the complications of a federal system, and the intricacies of California politics - all of these matters and more were implicated by the controversy surrounding Proposition 8. This roundtable discussion draws on leading experts who are eminently qualified to address these concerns, which go to the heart of defining the legal system’s role in a pluralistic society. Democracy’s Dilemma: The Case of Proposition 8 will be held from 8:30 - 10:15 a.m. on Friday, January 9, in the Marriott Hotel and Marina.
Proposition 8, Legal Challenges and The Future of Marriage Between Same- Sex Couples, one of four selected “Hot Topic Programs,” will also address the immediate issues raised by the passage of Proposition 8: constitutional challenges to Proposition 8, including the question whether the voter initiative validly “amended” the state constitution or instead illegally revised it, the future of the federal Defense of Marriage Act (”DOMA”) and legal and constitutional trends in other states with regard to this and related issues. Proposition 8, Legal Challenges and The Future Of Marriage Between Same-Sex Couples, will be held from 3:30 - 5:15 p.m. on Friday, January 9, 2009 in the Marriott Hotel and Marina.
The AALS Section on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Issues is also sponsoring several programs concerning same-sex rights. A day long program entitled Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Across the Curriculum: The Challenges of Keeping Law Schools Current with Recent Developments in Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Issues will feature sessions on: recent developments in sexual orientation and gender identity issues, transgender issues, employment discrimination and the Solomon Amendment. This Section’s program will be held on January 7 from 8:45 a.m. - 5:15 p.m. in the Marriott Hotel and Marina.
The entire AALS 2009 Annual Meeting program can be found on the Association’s Web site at www.aals.org/am2009/. Members of the press are invited to attend free of charge. Those interested in attending are asked to notify Deborah Quick from January 6-10, 2009 at 619-645-6955. Press also may register on-site at the AALS office located in the Manchester Room on the North Tower/Lobby Level of the San Diego Marriott Hotel & Marina beginning Tuesday after 6 p.m. January 6, 2009, and continuing through Saturday, January 10, 2009.
The Association of American Law Schools is a resource for the improvement of the quality of legal education by networking law school faculty, professional staff and deans to information and resources. AALS is the principal representative of legal education to the federal government, other national higher education organizations and learned societies.
Tags:
Act,
Address,
Aftermath,
Ally,
Amp,
Bisexual,
California Politics,
Cho,
Civi,
Civil Rights,
Civil Rights Protections,
Constitution,
Constitutional Challenges,
Controversial Issues,
Controversy,
Coord,
Cop,
Cou,
Couples,
Cultural Institution,
Dean,
Defense Of Marriage Act,
Democrat,
Disagreement,
Discrimination,
Doma,
Education,
elect,
Eve,
Exec,
Fo,
Fundamental Civil Rights,
gay,
Gender Identity,
google,
Hot Topic,
Images,
Initiative,
January 1,
Lars,
Lead,
Leads,
Legal Challenge,
Legal Challenges,
Legal Scholars,
Legality Of Same Sex Marriage,
lesbian,
Lt,
marriage,
Marriott,
Marriott Hotel,
Meaning Of Marriage,
Meeting Will Take Place,
Members,
Nbsp,
Nme,
Organization,
Original Source,
Pac,
People,
Pl,
Pluralistic Society,
politics,
Pos,
Register,
Roun,
Same Sex Couples,
same sex marriage,
Sec,
sex,
Sex Couple,
Sexual Orientation,
Stake,
State Constitution,
State Supreme Court,
Supreme Court,
Supreme Court Decision,
Target,
Ted,
Ties,
Transgender,
Venerable Traditions,
Vote,
Voter Initiative
High school principal decides against sacrificing his job in disagreement with gay-straight alliance.
Read more….
Tags:
Disagreement,
Gay Straight Alliance,
Gsa,
Job,
School Principal