Reader comments · Dutch minister stops gay ‘cure’ therapy health insurance · PinkNews

Enter your email address to receive our daily LGBT news roundup

You're free to unsubscribe at any time.


Dutch minister stops gay ‘cure’ therapy health insurance

Post your comment

Comments on this article are now closed.

Reader comments

  1. It’s a wonder to me that this was available in the first place with a country seen as being so ahead in gay equality. In the circumstance, all I can say is …At last !

  2. The inevitable product of gay “cure” is deluded fools posting on gay sites with the vain hope that they can demean what they themselves are not strong enough to face.

  3. I am from the Netherlands. Even though we were and maybe still are ahead in gay equality, moronic religious freaks are everywhere. This is something coming from the Dutch bible belt which you can compare with Mormon/Amish

    1. GingerlyColors 5 Jun 2012, 4:09pm

      Mormon without the second ‘m’ spells Moron.

      1. GingerlyColors 5 Jun 2012, 9:56pm

        Please note that I posted that before the article about Mormons marching with gays in support of LGBT rights in Salt Lake City was published. Not all Mormons are Morons. Apologies!

  4. I’m stunned that it was ever covered in the first place; especially in Holland! And that it’s taken until 2012 for them to decide that it wasn’t a good idea.

    1. Well in the Netherlands everybody is required to hold health insurance (either privately or government assisted) and in case of illness, claims are made to one’s health insurance company which insures people for most medical and psychological treatment.

      It wasn’t as if the gay ‘conversion therapy’ was being offered wholesale by hospitals or doctors. Vulnerable people were being bullied by their churches (usually) into taking this ‘therapy’ and claiming the cost back on their health insurance.

      And as it was deemed a psychological treatment, then the health insurance companies covered it.

      This new law seems to state that health insurance companies are not longer allowed to reimburse costs for ‘conversion therapy’.

      Which is a good thing, as it means people will be less willing to pay for dangerous treatment like ‘conversion therapy’ if they know their health insurance will not cover it.

  5. At least its gone now. Every little step forward is a good thing :)

  6. NaomiClareNL 5 Jun 2012, 2:38pm

    In the diagnosis-treatment system used here in the Netherlands there is no such thing as a cure for homosexuality. So it was administratively fudged a bit and therefore fly under the radar for so long.
    Glad the loophole is closed but there still remains a need for counselling for those poor souls. Not all of it can be handled by pastors, in all probablilty.

  7. Thank god for that, I honestly cannot believe that it was ever put on the basic health insurance in the first place. Even if homosexuality was ‘curable’ this would not be a matter of health.

  8. The Amish in America keep to themselves and don’t push their views on anyone outside their faith. Your religious freaks sound more like Mormons and the Christian fundamentalists of the American South.

  9. GingerlyColors 5 Jun 2012, 4:06pm

    The world’s most gay-friendly nation has become even more gay-friendly. I hope that the NHS and all other state-run health services around the world follow suit and stop offering quack medicine and concentrate on real problems such as cancer, heart disease and HIV.

  10. These anti-gay Christian psychiatrist are insane, they electric shock the penis of gay children to “make them straight”, this is really torture of a child and these anti-gay Christian psychiatrist need to be arrested and put in jail for crimes against humanity. These tortured gay children end up killing themselves as a result of all the harm these evil anti-gay Christian psychiatrist do to them.

    1. Paul, are you sure you aren’t engaging in a little hyperbole here. I have never heard of any ex-gay ministery (such as Exodus) actually doing what you suggest. I’ve heard that (laughably) they tell guys to snap a rubber band on their wrist if they feel any same sex attractions. Sure you aren’t thinking of Abu Ghraib?

      Please provide links to substantive documentation indicating which ex-gay therapists are currently using this kind of torture treatment.

  11. I woner in how many other countries gay conversion is covered. The Netherlands couldn’t have been the only one. This would be an important article to publish.

  12. Sister Mary Clarence 5 Jun 2012, 6:27pm

    What utter common sense on the part of Edith Schippers. Long overdue I’m sure but well done to her for taking the sensible approach

  13. Sister Mary Clarence 5 Jun 2012, 6:28pm

    What utter common sense on the part of Edith Schippers. Long overdue I’m sure but well done to her for taking the sensible approach

  14. This is good! “Gay cure” is harmful/dangerous and isn’t possible- you’re either pretending to be straight or are bisexual and repressing your homosexual attractions.

  15. (From May 23)
    Gay ‘cure’ therapist loses appeal against suspension.
    A Christian psychotherapist has lost her appeal against suspension from her professional body after being struck off after attempting to convert a homosexual man to heterosexuality.
    In 2009, campaigning journalist Patrick Strudwick used hidden tape recorders to catch Christian therapist Lesley Pilkington, who believes that homosexuality is sinful, offering to “cure” him using methods that have been condemned as dangerous.

  16. However, as counselling and psychotherapy is unregulated in the UK, Mrs Pilkington is still free to offer such services, but can no longer claim senior accredited status of the BACP.
    Stephen Evans, Campaigns Manager at the National Secular Society said Mrs Pilkington was “guilty of religiously inspired bigotry parading as psychotherapy.”
    He said: “There is no question of her religious freedoms being impeded. The important factor in the delivery of any therapy or counselling is that the professional providing the service adheres to their professional code of conduct. Mrs Pilkington clearly believes her religious beliefs are far more important than any code of conduct, which is why the BACP Governing body found unanimously that she was guilty of professional malpractice.”

  17. ‘repress their sinful urges’

    Let’s all just take a moment to look up the definition of repress and laugh heartily at this line.

    How in the world do you sell repression to people?

    “Sir! Sir! Please, a moment of your time. Are you finding that your emotions just bubble to the surface naturally, and are surprised by how lucid and balanced you’re feeling? You need repression! Comes in three sizes and six flavours! With our short course of treatments, you too could feel like a rat in a cage again! Why express feelings when you could simmer in contempt! Buy now get ‘passive aggression for repressed people’ for only half price!”

  18. Har Davids 6 Jun 2012, 10:14pm

    That’s what ‘freedom of religion’ can bring you, as we have our share if crazies, too. I support a therapy for these gay christians that will turn them into gay atheists or agnostics. I’m sure they’ll benefit from it.

  19. The ex-gay therapists can stay in business by sayng they are trresting their client for homosexual dystonia or GID both being recognized conditions in the DSM IV. And therapists are quite creative in how they get around insurance regulations…
    On the positive side, it will tend to discourage a therapist from offering unwelcome therapeutic advice to their gay clients… so there is some good here.

These comments are un-moderated and do not necessarily represent the views of PinkNews. If you believe that a comment is inappropriate or libellous, please contact us.