Potential new EU member states told to improve gay and trans laws

× Close window

Reader Comments

  1. D.McCabe  2 Apr 2012, 4:36pm  Report
    Thumb up 12Thumb down

    None of these countries should become part of the EU until they have had positive LGBT laws in place for at least three years and there is evidence oc positive change towards the LGBT community.

    Post a reply →
  2. Stuart Neyton  2 Apr 2012, 4:52pm  Report
    Thumb up 6Thumb down

    The same could be said for a fair few existing member states.

    Post a reply →
    1. Robert in S. Kensington  2 Apr 2012, 5:28pm  Report
      Thumb up 8Thumb down

      Exactly right. Greece and Italy aren’t doing such a great job either.

      Post a reply →
      1. Beberts  2 Apr 2012, 7:00pm  Report
        Thumb up 3Thumb down

        Spain and Portugal are doing very well.

        Post a reply →
      2. groovejet  3 Apr 2012, 12:12pm  Report
        Thumb up 4Thumb down

        I think the baltic countries are even worse. Didn’t they want to pass a law against gay people in Lithuania some years ago?

        Post a reply →
        1. Jonathan Kwan HC  22 Sep 2012, 1:25pm  Report
          Thumb up 1Thumb down

          Yeah, you’re so right. But don’t put Estonia in the same position. It’s one of the most atheist state in the world and the people are pretty tolerant to gays, even though it doesn’t recognize same-sex marriage and have no gay adoption.

          I want to say this because some people think Estonia is a “Baltic” country as put it in same position with its homophobic neighbors, while de facto it’s a Northern European country planning to join the Nordics.

          Post a reply →
  3. Robert in S. Kensington  2 Apr 2012, 5:24pm  Report
    Thumb up 1Thumb down

    Indeed they should not become members until they have a proven track record of reform protecting the rights of LGBT people. I don’t think any of them are going to comply. Religion has a stronghold on those countries, deeply embedded.

    Post a reply →
  4. Lumi Bast  2 Apr 2012, 5:40pm  Report
    Thumb up 7Thumb down

    Every country that’s in the EU should have COMPLETE rights for it’s LGB citizens/visitors

    Post a reply →
  5. Dromio  2 Apr 2012, 5:48pm  Report
    Thumb up 3Thumb down

    It would be a big step forward if marriages conducted in one EU country had to be recognised in other EU countries.

    Post a reply →
    1. Robert in S. Kensington  2 Apr 2012, 6:06pm  Report
      Thumb up 4Thumb down

      Yes indeed, but the ECHR will have none of it and has stated quite some ago that it is not intefering in the marriage equality issue of member states. How convenient. It should be one of the prerequisites for membership but that’s not going to happen.

      Post a reply →
  6. Bill (Scotland)  2 Apr 2012, 8:30pm  Report
    Thumb up 2Thumb down

    This is just window-dressing and is the latest ‘ploy’ (no doubt by Germany and France) to keep Turkey out of the EU.

    Similar promises were required of other recent joiners (Poland, Slovakia, etc) before they joined, but post-membership enforcement or punishment for non-compliance has been non-existent. Not to mention the similar flouting of the commitments of various new-joiners to improve the treatment of their ‘Roma’ citizens (Romania, Slovakia, for example).

    This is simply meaningless window-dressing. Once a country is in the EU the reality is that it has a vote like any other member so can block/flout rules it does not like. Just look at the way Cyprus (southern half) has flouted the commitments made to Cyprus (northern half) by the EU when the former blocked the latter from joining as a full member.

    Although I am basically pro-EU its double-standards make me sick.

    Post a reply →
  7. Yeah the EU said the same thing about Poland, Latvia and Lithuania. ALL were admitted and ALL passed very anti-gay laws (think Section 28) after gaining EU membership.

    Post a reply →
  8. Three of these countries need to be completely rebuilt from the ground up before the EU opens the doors, and not just on LGBT issues. Serbia is so corrupt I’m amazed the EU is even entertaining the notion of entry.

    I hope that Brussels is just dangling a carrot in the hope that they can pressure for some reform. Allowing more of these backward Balkan states in as they stand would be an incredibly bad move.

    Post a reply →

Add your comment

These comments are un-moderated and do not necessarily represent the views of PinkNews.co.uk. If you believe that a comment is inappropriate or libellous please click "Report" or email us. Terms and Conditions · Privacy Policy




Top users this week

  • Robert in S. Kensington 811
  • Eddy 339
  • bobbleobble 283
  • Jock S. Trap 281
  • D.McCabe 241
  • rapture 190
  • Rehan 189
  • Ray123 181
  • SteveC 173
  • Valksy 164