Reader comments · Stephen Gately’s record label makes official complaint about Jan Moir article · PinkNews

Enter your email address to receive our daily LGBT news roundup

You're free to unsubscribe at any time.


Stephen Gately’s record label makes official complaint about Jan Moir article

Post your comment

Comments on this article are now closed.

Reader comments

  1. Brian Burton 21 Oct 2009, 6:28pm

    Polydos action is ‘Grit to the Mill’ I suppose. Pity Polydor did not Bother till now?

  2. Simon Murphy 21 Oct 2009, 6:57pm

    Does Jan Moir have a column every Friday in the Mail?

    I’m curious to see if she has one this week and if so then what she will have to say. Surely if the Mail decide to run another article by her, she cannot avoid addressing what happened since last Friday.

    If she refuses to apologise for her vicious spite (on the day before Stephen Gately’s funeral) and tries to justify herself, then I expect the Daily Heil will face a repeat of last week.

  3. They’ve got a bit of financial clout. they might be able to use it. They could claim that her slanderous comments might affect sales of Boyzone cds or something? That makes them directly affected and that was what the PCC said they needed to act.

  4. How can there be justice when the PCC chairman is paid by the Daliy Mail!?!?! This is going to be a farce!

  5. I don’t know, Stephen. I’m just trying to see something positive in this whole sad saga. Yes, I know, the Rose-tinted glasses. But that’s me.

  6. If the PCC refuses to act or does as little as it can, I hope everyone who complained then asks their MP what they hope to do about it. In an election year, it could be effective.

  7. Why do we have to see the Moir woman’s pork pie face leering at us in all these stories?

  8. Sister Mary Clarence 22 Oct 2009, 3:59am

    Word in the press seems to be that the complaints to the PCC will get nowhere. However the PCC is under review at the present time and submissions to the review board are welcomed (apparently!)

    Buscombe announces independent PCC governance review

    Buscombe announces independent PCC governance review
    In her first major initiative since taking over as Chairman of the Press Complaints Commission in April 2009, Baroness Buscombe has announced plans for an independent review of the PCC’s governance. The review group will examine the operation of the PCC board, sub-committees and secretariat; how transparency in the system can be enhanced; whether the independent systems of accountability – the Charter Commissioner and Charter Compliance Panel – can be improved; and the PCC’s Articles of Association.
    Announcing the move, Lady Buscombe said:
    “I have been impressed by many aspects of the PCC’s work since I took over as Chairman – not least, the extent to which it works hard behind the scenes to minimise intrusion and resolve complaints quickly and amicably. However, there has not been an independent review of the PCC’s governance since it was created in 1991, and I think it is important periodically to reflect on the way an organisation works to make sure we have taken account of good practice elsewhere and wider public expectations. The review group will also want to consider the findings of the Select Committee on Culture, Media and Sport when it completes its report later this summer on press standards, privacy and libel.
    “For all those reasons, I have asked Vivien Hepworth – who has experience of many different bodies in the public, private and NGO sectors as well as the PCC – to chair this review. She is stepping down before the end of her final term on the PCC board in order to undertake this review, and I have asked for her report in Spring 2010. Further appointments to the review group will be made shortly.”
    Vivien Hepworth said: “I am honoured to have been asked by Peta Buscombe to chair this governance review. I am a strong believer in self-regulation of the press, but it must constantly adapt in order to prosper. It is the right time for a fresh and independent look at the areas this review will consider. In my view, this initiative underlines the PCC’s flexibility – something that is one of the hallmarks and advantages of non-statutory regulation. I will step down from the board of the PCC before this review group starts work in the autumn”.
    1. Vivien Hepworth is Executive Chairman of Grayling in the UK and Brussels. She has been a Lay Member of the PCC since October 2001. A former Chairman of Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Hospital Trust, she is also a Trustee of the Prince’s Foundation for the Built Environment, Vice-Chairman of the College of St Barnabas and the founder and Hon President of the Nystagmus Network, a self-help group for those with certain rare visual impairments and their families.
    2. Three further appointments to the review group will be made, including another independent member and one with senior experience of the newspaper and magazine industry.
    3. It will work for approximately six months, before making recommendations to the board of the PCC in spring 2010.
    4. For more information, contact Tim Toulmin on 020 7831 0022.

    It might be appropriate to address comments on the current in effectiveness of the PCC and its codes or practice to the review board in the event the complaints do not get addressed.

  9. Jean-Paul Bentham 22 Oct 2009, 8:47am

    “The PPC, whose chairman Paul Dacre is the editor of the Daily Mail, usually only deals with complaints from those directly affected by articles.”

    That’s pretty clear to me.

    The 22,000 complaints were received from persons who were not affected by Moir’s viewpoint.

    O-o-o-o-o-o-o, now I see why the merry-go-round has so many mirrors!

  10. It all boils down to “Who watches the Watchmen” doesn’t it. Someone has to chair the PCC, and who can guarantee their impartiality without being under the same level of scrutiny? Does it get put to the vote ever?

These comments are un-moderated and do not necessarily represent the views of PinkNews. If you believe that a comment is inappropriate or libellous, please contact us.