Reader comments · Row deepens over ordination of gay minister as insults fly · PinkNews

Enter your email address to receive our daily LGBT news roundup

You're free to unsubscribe at any time.


Row deepens over ordination of gay minister as insults fly

Post your comment

Comments on this article are now closed.

Reader comments

  1. Mr. Rennie.

    Just dump the lot!

    Get on with your life in the way you choose to live it and in another sphere.

    You are not ministering to Christians in any case; you are ministering to bean-counters, letter-of-the-law observers, Pharisees, tits..!
    They wouldn’t know a Christian precept if it hit them in the face.
    Look at all the poverty and homelessness around and don’t bother going to Africa to do it, laudable as that may be.
    It is in every shop doorway at night; the bum, the wino, the bag-lady, the druggie.
    “Let me take you thro’ the streets of London…”…and all that.

    Christ would be ministering to those ‘scumbags’ as he ministered to the scumbags of his own times; he even died, crucified, between two such ‘scumbags’.
    I do not think he would be overly worried, were He here now, about whether Cedric and Cyril are getting it ‘on’ or not; or be over-fussed whether Arthur really wants to be Martha.

    These (excuse me while I pee mesel’ laffin) ‘Christians’ haven’t a clue about the founding principle of their Master.

  2. Dave North 14 May 2009, 7:40pm

    I always wondered.

    If Christ had died by guillotine, would all the good ickle chwistians be wearing silver guillotines round their necks, or genuflicting infront of massive ones in their temples of hypocrisy.

    Seems to me they dont “think” very much about it.


  3. The trouble with historically orthodox Christianity is that it is neither true nor even merely benign.

    This is why Christianity has produced so many viciously nasty shoots like Forward Together who believe they are ‘triumphing over the powers of darkness in spiritual warfare’ when they attack and slander those with differing views… It’s Biblical!!!.

    This is where unfortunate Liberal Christians like Scott Rennie and his supporters find themselves ‘hoist by their own petard’.

    No matter how progressive or well intended we may be, we can’t rewrite the Bible or alter the decisions of the Church Councils that produced the creeds.

    Christianity will ALWAYS have an element of violent exclusivity, paranoid black-and-white thinking and histrionic apocalypticism – simply because that’s in the Bible… it’s in the New Testament! It’s ‘the Faith Once Delivered to the Saints’!

    It’s even attributed by the Biblical authors to Jesus himself! Anyone even debating with him is portrayed as a ‘hypocrite’ a ‘fool’, Jewish ‘opponents’ are ‘children of the devil’. He even refers to a Canaanite (or was it Syrophoenician? – both, actually) woman & her daughter as ‘dogs’!!!. Gentiles are ‘dogs’ and ‘swine’… I could go on, but it would be tedious…

    Where the Liberal’s inclusive luvvie Jesus comes from, God alone knows! – it certainly isn’t from the plain sense of the NT!

    I really feel for Scott Rennie – that he’s suffered so much distress over this issue and has been attacked in such an intimate area of his life…It’s a truly horrible way to wake up to the reality of the poisoned chalice that is Christianity – but maybe it IS time to wake up, Scott (and Liberal Christians generally), and stop drinking – and peddling – the wine of delusion.

  4. Abi Chrisopher 14 May 2009, 7:59pm

    If they believe the book of lies surly Rev Georgie Baxendale, one of Scotland’s first female preachers who is protesting Rev Scott Rennie is also an abomination to the church also.

    The hypocrisy of this must escape her and Forward Together I bet they eat shrimp also!

  5. Here’s a fine example from the Sunday Times of the ‘sane and balanced’ thinking that goes on even in the Liberal Christian mind:

    [Rev Kenneth MacKenzie, the minister at Crathie Kirk, near Balmoral]…The Queen’s minister has warned that the appointment of his friend and protégé as the Church of Scotland’s first openly gay clergyman would lead to an “apocalyptic” split in the Kirk.

    If this is an accurate, verbatim quote, it’s worrying that this degree of black-and-white thinking now pervades even the Liberal wing of the Kirk!

    No, Kenneth, the split WON’T be Apocalyptic. It may be a very big, very ugly blow-out, followed by schism, but what it will NOT be is Apocalyptic…

    …just like the NON-apocalyptic NON-arrival of the Kingdom of God in the 1st century (as predicted by Jesus and the apostles, according to the Bible)!!!

  6. Brian Burton 14 May 2009, 9:38pm

    There is mutiny in the ranks of Kirk and Captain Rennie is luckily supported by his first Leutenant Georgie Baxindale. Cutlasses in hand the Evangelical mutineers circle their prey. 80% of Rennie’s congregation support their Captain but are scattered around on shore and are not to hand. What will the heroic Captain do as he and his Leutenant dodge the cut and thrust of the mutineers cutlasses….. Tune in tomorrow to this fight to the death!

  7. Brian Burton 15 May 2009, 9:55am

    Tommorow never comes you know! Still Captain Rennie, back to the wall, is in no mood to listen to ‘Give it all up advice. It is alright for people who do not have a salaried position, to say give it up and also give up your salary in this ressesion. Another 15,000 from British Telecom to be put out of work and there will be many more–Becha! So Captain Couragous Rennie Fight, fight with all your might. Christ is thy strength and Christ thy right. You have only one life, so live it.
    Each man or woman lives their own life and pays the price of that life. But, you can pay over and over again and Gay people usually have to do this. You will in life run up against the so-called ‘moral’ who are heartless, cruel, vindictive, log-stupid and entirely lacking in humanity.

  8. Stuff the homophobes. Let them defect to Catholicism. I am sure Razi-Nazi would love them.

  9. It’s not often that I care about people who are religious; there seems to be no right or wrong with the cherry-picking morality of fictional literature, and it’s a fault to believe in it in the first place. Still, I just think it’s hilarious that the opposition is trying to gain credibility through the like of Fred Phelps! What a joke…

  10. What a wonderful display of Christian love and compassion in action

    . . . thin not

  11. Brian Burton 16 May 2009, 2:28pm

    Caught up with you again Captain Rennie! You are you and your enimies at your door will be vanquished because right will win over tyrrany. Your opposition are a tedious pack of idiots, who haven’t the remotest knoledge of how to live, nor the smallest instinct about when to die.

  12. Alex, Brisbane, Qld 17 May 2009, 8:12am

    Doesn’t it just show what fools the forward together people are, getting good ole Fred in on their protests. I can’t wait for them to meet and swop stories..! I wonder how fast they’ll then back-peddle!

  13. Father Adrian T 18 May 2009, 3:11am

    One of the most obvious things that the gaystapo have forgotten is how is the said homosexual priest going to condemn acts of fornication, adultery, incest, bestiality, swingers and polygamists to name a few.

    If homosexuality is approved by the bible as he obviously wrongly believes, he is in no position to apply the teaching of the bible about other sexual sins.

    I can just see it now on a sign outside the church.



  14. I see “Father Adrian T” has emerged as another sub-personality of the generic, paranoid, black-and-white thinking dysfunctional fundamentalist troll who has nothing better to do than hang around LGBT sites & also posts under the pseudonyms of david skinner, reality check various other moronic pseudonyms.

    Wakey, wakey troll!!!



    What part of DELUDED do you not understand, “Christian”?!!!

  15. Brian Burton 19 May 2009, 8:29am

    Don’t say your still floating about like a CONTAMINATED SPERM BUBBLE! Looks like you got your work cut out with the whole of Show Biz. comming out as Bi-sexual etcetera. But Still, whatever you call yourself Skinner. You will have to grovel at out feet for a long, long time!

  16. Archdeaon Brian Hurtin 19 May 2009, 1:24pm

    QUOTE: I see “Father Adrian T” has emerged as another sub-personality of the generic, paranoid, black-and-white thinking dysfunctional fundamentalist troll who has nothing better to do than hang around LGBT sites & also posts under the pseudonyms of david skinner, reality check various other moronic pseudonyms.

    You really do need to see an anger management professional.

    QUOTE: What part of DELUDED do you not understand, “Christian”?!!!

    Obviously not the delusion that you live under!!

    QUOTE: You will have to grovel at out feet for a long, long time!

    I stopped believing in fairy stories when I got older. Sorry to hear that you haven’t worked that one out yet. But then you might still be a child. Probably are judging by the fantasies you dream up.

  17. Reality Check 19 May 2009, 1:26pm

    Jas 1:15 Then when lust has conceived, it brings forth sin. And sin, when it is fully formed, brings forth death.

  18. Brian Burton 19 May 2009, 4:35pm

    Cesspool Sally Skinner……Umph off!

  19. Brian Burton 19 May 2009, 4:38pm

    Cesspool Sally, what a sutable name for you my dear!

  20. Brian Burton 19 May 2009, 4:48pm

    Now to Get back to some sanity, away from the Skinner Loony Fringe.
    Keep fighting you wonderful Gay Minister Rennie. Don’t let the Terrorists get you down. Gay people in all walks of life are made of very stern stuff. The oppersition you have are basically weak minded people where as the Gay mind is strong and resolute–Your enimies will be vanquished!

  21. @Archdeaon Brian Hurtin

    An unconsciously appropriate pseudonym, perhaps?

    It does, doesn’t it, “Brian”?

    …and the sad thing is, it doesn’t need to, not nearly so much,

    …because the prison you’re in is largely of your own choosing,

    …and you can choose to leave, as soon as you’re willing to value truth more than dogma…

  22. Brian Burton 20 May 2009, 5:59pm


  23. Archdeacon Brian Hurtin 25 May 2009, 7:38am

    Mat 5:10 Blessed are they which are persecuted for righteousness’ sake: for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
    Mat 5:11 Blessed are ye, when men shall revile you, and persecute you, and shall say all manner of evil against you falsely, for my sake.
    Mat 5:12 Rejoice, and be exceeding glad: for great is your reward in heaven:

  24. Archdeacon Brian Hurtin 27 May 2009, 12:45am

    Joh 11:25 Jesus said to her, “I am the resurrection and the life. The person who believes in me, even though he dies, will live. Indeed, everyone who lives and believes in me will never die.

These comments are un-moderated and do not necessarily represent the views of PinkNews. If you believe that a comment is inappropriate or libellous, please contact us.